Some of you have noticed the shower gel seems different. Indeed it is. That tingly feeling and new peppermint smell is because we have had to switch to Dr. Bronner’s Pure Castile Soap made with organic oils. It does contain peppermint which gives that tingly sensation. Peppermint also has an energizing quality. I put it in the Nutragena bottles not to mislead you, but because Dr. Bronner’s does not come in a pump bottle. Costco has discontinued carrying Nutragena Shower Gel. If they start carrying it again I will switch back. In the meantime, I hope you all are enjoying this shower gel. I know it is a little thinner, but hopefully it is doing a nice job of cleaning and has a pleasant smell and feel.